American Pie 2 (2001)

Our favorite former virgins return after a year away at college in the second film of the American Pie trilogy, American Pie 2 (2001). The boys are back home for the summer, but find that the cops in their hometown don't appreciate loud house parties, so Jim (Jason Biggs), Oz (Chris Klein), Kevin (Thomas Ian Nicholas), Finch (Eddie Kaye Thomas) and Stifler (Sean William Scott) pool their funds and rent a beach house on Lake Michigan. While working as painters to pay for it, Jim hears that his high school dreamgirl Nadia (Shannon Elizabeth) is going to visit, and decides to track down his horny ginger prom date Michelle (Alyson Hannigan) for some sex practice, so he doesn't prematurely spew his goo again. The problem is, Jim starts to catch feelings for Michelle and needs to win her back after his buddies try to get her out of the way so Jim can do the naughty with Nadia. That's the basic plot, but since this is an American Pie movie there are all sorts of gross out gags involving jerking it with super glue that looked like lube, Finch doing all sorts of sexual stuff with Stifler's mom, and the painting gig turning into a peeping gig. As Nadia, Shannon's cannons don't come out to play in the sequel, but she does wear a bikini, as does the blonde babe Bree Turner. But the nudity that will have you thinking about penetrating a pie comes from Lisa Arturo and Denise Faye. The pair play a lesbian couple that hired the crew to paint their house, but catch the gang creeping on them while they take their clothes off. When they catch the boys while looking for their sex toys, they don't call the cops. Instead, they both show their funbags while playing with each other. Their game is simple, whatever the boys do to each other, they'll do to each other. But the fun and games end when the boys aren't willing to jerk each other off. Don't worry though, they'll both be all over Stifler's stiffy before the movie's through! Sequels traditionally disappoint, but that's because they don't make a point to have all sorts of Sapphic situations like American Pie 2!