Paul Preiss is Ryan, a college student who’s on the verge of a nervous breakdown from the nightmares that have plagued him since his sister Amy (Rachel Taylor) went missing eight years ago in the horror flick The Legend of Bloody Mary (2008). Amy’s unexplained disappearance came after playing the children’s game Bloody Mary, in which the player chants the name Bloody Mary while staring into a mirror to summon the vengeful spirit of a dead witch named Mary Worth (Caitlin Wachs). Ryan’s girlfriend Rachel (Irina Costa) enlists the help of priest and archaeologist Father O’Neal (Robert J. Locke) to find out what happened to Amy and cure Ryan's nightmares. Along the way, we get to see Irina's mam-marys twice. They’re the stuff of legend.