If you're a longtime fan of How I Met Your Mother, you already know that the "slutty pumpkin" is The One That Got Away, a woman Ted (Josh Radnor) met at a Halloween party ten years earlier and has been searching for ever since. If you're not, well, we just explained it to you.

Anyway, it was a big deal when Katie Holmes signed on to play the sleazy squash on the successful sitcom, and it's an even BIGGER deal now that we have, courtesy of our friends at Egotastic!, some potential nippage from the elusive Mrs. Cruise.

We're sending the pic in to the Skin Labs for further skinspection, but what's your take, Skin fans? Is that Katie's knob peeking out on her right hand side, or is (t)it merely a shadow?:




Mr. Skin members can see much, much more of Katie Holmes in The Gift (2000), right here at MrSkin.com!